Case Study
Gino Plagiarism Allegations
Investigated by a Montreal-based postdoc, then Science magazine
Separate from the Data Colada data-fabrication findings, a Montreal-based postdoctoral researcher (transcribed in Episode 221 as "Erin Acklund" — spelling unconfirmed) began independently investigating Francesca Gino's published books out of curiosity and found apparent plagiarism in the opening sentence of the first passage she examined, from Gino's book Rebel Talent. Science magazine then ran its own full investigation across Gino's body of published work and found several further examples:
- Rebel Talent — a passage describing Milan's fashion quarter (specific street names, luxury boutiques, ivy-covered walls, miniature fountains) closely matches a 2014 English-language travel website's description of the same district, predating the book by four years.
- Rebel Talent — a retelling of the Toy Story 2 plot (Woody's arm injury, his kidnapping, meeting Jessie), including specific phrases like "doomed to spend the rest of their lives separated from children by thick glass," closely matches a 2017 magazine plot summary.
- Sidetracked (2013) — an account of Ken Olsen and Digital Equipment Corporation's decline (its early dominance, the rise of Sun Microsystems, the shift to Unix) closely matches a 2011 Forbes article on the same subject.
- Dishonesty Explained, a 2016 book chapter co-authored with Dan Ariely — a passage on compliance and internal reward/punishment ("compliance with these values and norms results in internal rewards... whereas non-compliance results in internal punishment...") is near-identical to a 2014 doctoral thesis by Jasper Beneveld, with no citation.
- The same book chapter's summary of the Milgram obedience experiment (the progression of shocks, signs of participant distress, conclusions about authority) closely matches the specific language and structure of a 2008 published paper's own summary of the same experiment.
Assessment: Science's investigation found both direct textual overlap and structural similarity across multiple books, suggesting a consistent pattern rather than an isolated lapse — compounding the data-fabrication findings and further undermining confidence in Gino's wider body of published work. See Data Colada Gino Investigation.
Discussed in
- Episode 221 — 221-francesca-gino-scandal-what-really-happened